What’s the best use of a non-signup bonus 5% Office Supply store card for MS? I have one of the Chase cards that gives 5% and an AMEX SimplyCash card - both are capped to $25k or $50k per year to get t he 5% back on.
From my initial research I see Staples sells $300 gift cards online for an $8.95 fee which is a 3% fee. Add in a 70 cent money order and I’m making under 2%.
In store, Office Max/Office Depot and Staples seem to sell $200 cards for a $6.95 fee, which is even worse than this.
Is there any better options than this available for a 5% Office Supply card? Assuming I can cap out $50k in spend across both cards per year, I make under $1,000 in profit and have to liquidate 168 gift cards of $300 each. That hardly seems worth $1,000.
I know people used to lose their sh-- over 5% Office Supply cards, so I imagine either an older method of MSing them got shut down, or there’s something else I did not yet discover over than $9 fee on a $300 card and hoping Staples doesn’t shut me down, the USPS doesn’t lose any of my 168 gift cards, WalMart is okay with me buying $50k of MOs, and my local bank is okay with me depositing $50k worth of money orders, and AMEX/Chase are okay with me spending $25k each at Office Supply Stores per year.
A lot has to go right just for me to make $1,000 here. I don’t know the Wal Mart MO daily limit but assuming I can do $2k that’s still 25 trips - one trip per two weeks if I want to spread it out throughout the year. Assume best case scenario and each trip takes only 15 minutes when you add in parking, walking inside, waiting in line, getting the MO, walking back out, and getting out of the parking lot, that would be about 6 hours of time. Let’s add in a few minutes to deposit the MOs, and I’m still looking at $150 per hour. That’s not bad! Even if I messed up quite a bit, it’s still $100 an hour.
So even though it seems like a low amount of money ($1k), the hourly rate of return seems good. The problem comes into play that it’s not scalable since I’m limited in 5% cards, and there’s multiple failure points as described above.
Very interested in hearing how experienced MSers use their 5% Office Cards - I think once I do my annual allotment of AMEX BCP, I will switch to Office Spend next!