I read that as 95% MS …
1 Like
It doesn’t read that way, but perhaps that is what he meant.
if 95% were legitimate, he would be much more forthcoming about the denied charges 
But I don’t think we are talking gift cards and money orders here. A million a year has to be much more streamlined, hence why he doesn’t want to share and break his ‘fragile’ system. Don’t really blame him I guess.
Thanks, loper. Much appreciated.
Good grief! Yes, of course I’m talking about MS, which was jaytrader’s question in the first place. He wrote that my MS needed to be over 50%. I merely confirmed that it is WAAAAAY over 50%. I wrote it is over 95% . . . . and I can assure you it is WELL over 95%.
My God, do you think if I were doing a million/year of actual spending that I would be posting here? Heck, I’d be off on some Pacific island cultivating friendships with the local beauties! 
ETA
OK, sorry. Argyll is right, as usual. I went back and re-read jaytrader’s post where he asked the question. The way he wrote it sort of got me turned around and I ended up answering backwards. But I still say if I were actually spending $1M/year, as opposed to “spending” $1M/year, I would be unlikely to be posting here. That is pretty elite territory.
Why are we continuing to have this debate? NFCU doesn’t provide rewards for some type of activity that the poster is unwilling to share. Not blaming anyone, but it’s not particularly relevant to anyone else if we don’t have more specifics.
If people don’t want to share their specific strategies so the rest of us can try to develop an understanding of how to avoid triggers, that’s fine, but it’s not helpful to consistently read about people bragging about their unspecified MSing opportunities. Many people here have their own methods. Most, if not all, do not share those methods here (a mindset I personally agree with). Why continue to say, over and over, “I have this method that makes me tons of money, but I’m not going to share it with you.” If you want to create a heavy hitters thread, do that, and share your unspecified successes there. Otherwise, every single bank thread doesn’t have to be peppered with constant comments about how a secret MS method does or doesn’t work with that bank.
7 Likes
I agree this discussion doesn’t belong in the NFCU thread. Maybe shinobi should be commenting on another thread, like an MS thread.
By the way, I am doing $5 million a year in MS but I can’t tell you what I’m doing.
2 Likes
Congrats, Argyll. I always knew you were the man! I want to be like you. 
I opened another NFCU Flagship Rewards account today. The previous one was opened December last year and I closed it in April after collecting $580 rewards on $4000 spend (14.5%).
I plan to do the same thing again. Ssshh!
2 Likes
So the Flagship is churnable, huh? How did you close it–just a secure message? Were you able to recover any of the credit line, and transfer it to another card before closing?
I closed it by phone and transferred the entire credit line to two existing cards.
2 Likes
NFCU continues CD rate leadership with certain certificates, 18 month and five year:
Details from CD discussion thread
ETA
Here is the new NFCU rate sheet. It became effective several hours ago:
3 Likes
The NFCU Cash Rewards is 1.5% and there’s no minimum to redeem. I wish they’d increase it to 2%. I’ve been using State Department FCU’s 2% card. I converted the Alliant 2.5% card (because I didn’t want to pay the higher fee) to the free 2% card but see no reason to use the Alliant card when there are so many other 2% alternatives. Wish I didn’t miss the boat on USAA’s Limitless.
I use the Alliant card because for me it works out to over 2% even with the fee, and 2.1% or 2.2% is better than 2%.
1 Like
Even with the fee increased to $99? You spend a lo more than I do. 
NFCU doesn’t allow ACH’s out of the shares savings account, so yeah, you would need a checking account to ACH out. I highly doubt they would limit to $5k on ACH pulls.
2 Likes
When I open and add to NFCU CDs, I call and the the transfer is done to my NFCU savings account.
The funds are automatically transferred to the CD a few days later. I receive double interest for a few days.
1 Like
Please note: All times in this post refer to eastern time
I have two NFCU data points to report. I’ve been doing the NFCU five year CDs. I can report NFCU updates its CD rate sheet each night at, or just after, midnight. The rate sheet thereafter is good for the next 24 hours. Is it the same on weekends? I dunno.
The opening of NFCU certificates required me to be ACHing funds into my NFCU checking. As you know, it is straightforward to open NFCU CDs online from funds in checking.
When we went from July into August I was concerned they would drop the rate (they did not) so I was watching the NFCU website during the overnight. I noticed the darndest thing which is the second data point I want to report. I’ve not seen anything like this prior . . anywhere.
I had ACHed funds from two different places, Alliant and PurePoint, the last day of July. The Alliant funds were dispatched just after 1:00 PM, and the PurePoint funds left even later in the day. Both deposits were showing and available in my NFCU checking at 2:30 AM on August first. That is the earliest I ever have experienced ACHed funds, dispatched the prior day, arriving at their destination. Customarily such funds would not appear until between 5:00 AM and 8:00 AM, or whatever . . . sometimes even later than that.
NFCU is REALLY on the ball to be doing ACH account credits so early.
Caveat:
Course I really do not know exactly when NFCU credited those funds to my checking. All I know is that they were there at 2:30 AM. And there is no jeopardy in account credits anyway.
But clearly NFCU is running their ACH files hours before I would have anticipated, or at least they certainly were that night. That is fine for ACH deposits. But if you are hitting your NFCU checking with an ACH withdrawal, be on notice it could hit the account really early.
Q: Shin, are you suggesting an ACH withdrawal could hit a member’s NFCU account the same day it was initiated at an outside financial institution?!
Far be it from me to suggest any such thing. I am merely your humble reporter, here only to present a couple of data points as I experienced them.
But you be thoughtful and careful out there. NFCU is doing stuff I have not seen previously anywhere else.
UncaMikey. When a CD matures you must move the funds to either a checking or savings account at some institution. (I use Alliant CU) Then set up ACH transfers at NFCU (routing # etc.) Next ACH funds to checking, savings at NFCU. Then call rep & have funds moved into the CD. Really simple. 
1 Like
I have not studied the above posts sufficiently to be certain. Sorry.
But I’m going to risk error here and propose UncaMikey might not understand the concept of having a hub account. It’s only a guess.
I think we all have hub accounts and just take that for granted. Pattyb53 mentioned Alliant. And she has also referred to having an account at PurePoint. I happen to use both of those service providers as hub accounts also.
I cannot imagine financial management without help from at least one hub account. I’m pretty sure I could not do it. I’d be contorted into a pretzel trying to move money around quickly and efficiently.
Ya gotta have a hub account which provides overnight ACH service. Anyone lacking that resource . . . well . . . that is problem #1.
I think you guys are not understanding the point about NFCU and ACH. When a CD matures at NFCU, or if you simply want to transfer money out of your share account to boost your checking account at another institution, you can’t do that. You must either maintain a checking account there, or engage a human being on the phone after going through phone menus and see if you can get an exception.
For me, I begrudgingly opened a checking account, and you can do internal transfers at NFCU instantaneously online. My gripe with it is having yet another account/account number/registry/statement to reconcile/etc. It’s not the end of the world, just unnecessarily complicated. Still for me, that’s better than having to make a phone call.
Two other annoying things about NFCU that I’m sure I’ve mentioned before … 1) You can’t automatically pay your credit card bill in full each month. I’ve got 25+ credit card accounts and NFCU is the only one that doesn’t allow this, and 2) they require multi-factor authentication every stinkin’ transaction download. It is a generally acceptable risk to use the fact that you have multi-factored with this device already in combination with username/password credentials, but not NFCU. I know Argyll will say this is more secure, and I won’t argue with that … it is. But security is a risk management problem, and NFCU are beyond the industry standards on this one.
All that said, I love NFCU and have no other issues with them. I use them quite a bit. The annoyances I mentioned are minor in comparison to egregious atrocities as one might find at, oh, Synchrony.
2 Likes