I agree this could get complicated, especially if you use Ally’s checking account actively.
What about the monthly bills and withdrawals you make on your checking account? Does that subtract away from the deposit you made during the qualifying period?
Below, I reproduce a post I found on Bogleheads:
I have a few questions about the terms and conditions for the 1% payback promotion, which I have already read (so please don’t just quote those terms back to me in answering these questions). The questions are mostly about exactly how you count “new money” during the deposit period of 10/8/2018 - 11/5/2018, and how deposits and withdrawals during the retention period affect the bonus. Since I use my Ally checking accounts to pay my bills, there have been and will continue to be ongoing deposits and withdrawals from my eligible accounts.
Deposit period
-------------------
Say there are withdrawals of $5,000 from my checking accounts, mostly to pay bills, between 10/8/2018 and 11/5/2018. Must I deposit $100,000 or $105,000 during this period to qualify for the maximum bonus of $1,000?
Assuming the answer is $105,000, do bills paid out of my wife’s and my joint checking account count against both my wife’s and my “new money” in full, or one half for each of us?
Retention period.
----------------------
_Say I put $100,000 into an 11-month no-penalty CD by 11/5/2018, and leave it in the CD account until 1/15/2019, at which time I do an early withdrawal and transfer it out of Ally, but I still have other eligible accounts open into which the bonus can be deposited until 2/15/2019. During the retention period, I continue to make deposits and withdrawals from my Ally checking accounts. _
Do you subtract withdrawals from deposits during the retention period, and compare it to the balances in all eligible accounts as of 11/5/2018 to determine if I’ve maintained the full $100K in eligible accounts during the retention period?
Assuming it works this way, do you look at the minimum balance at any time between 11/5/2018 and 1/15/2019 to see if it is less than the total balances in all eligible accounts as of 11/5/2018, or do you look only at the balance as of 1/15/2019 compared to the balance as of 11/5/2018?
POD accounts. Trust accounts are not eligible accounts, but there is no mention of POD accounts. Are accounts with POD designations eligible accounts? I ask because these also are referred to as Totten trust accounts
Refusal to pay cash bonus. I am concerned about the second part of this clause in the consent terms: “Ally Bank reserves the right to refuse to open an account or pay out the Cash Bonus, at any time, for any reason.” How do I know Ally will not simply refuse to pay the bonus within 30 calendar days at the end of the retention period without providing any reason, even if I have met all of the stated conditions? This clause seems to make that possible. What are examples of things that might cause Ally not to pay the bonus?