The deal is dead!
DEAD: 1 oz Gold American Eagle | Random Date US Mint Coin
Buy it with a 2% cash-back credit card and your cost is $20 or so below spot price -or- choose PayPal credit at checkout and get no interest and no payments for six months.
For perspective, you’ll most-frequently find 1 Oz. coins like this on eBay for around $100 over spot price. If you bought direct or through a large dealer that isn’t paying payment fees or eBay fees, you should be able to get them for $50 over spot price instead.
When you sell them, you should expect to sell them at spot price. If you’re offered less than $5 UNDER spot price, you’re not getting a fair offer. $5 or $10 ABOVE spot price is a very generous offer.